Welcome to New York Style Pizzeria
New York Style Pizzeria, located in Collierville, TN, is a gem for pizza lovers seeking authentic New York flavor. Specializing in classic NY-style pizza, they serve up chewy, foldable slices that transport you straight to the streets of New York City. Patrons rave about the well-done crust and commend the owner’s 28 years of pizza-making experience. From mouthwatering cheese pizzas to enticing specialty options, each bite promises satisfaction. With a cozy atmosphere and a focus on quality, it’s a must-visit for anyone craving a slice that captures the essence of New York pizza. Experience true pizza artistry here!
New York Style Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Damn good pizza! As the name suggests they specialize in NY style pizza: Chewy crust and large pieces that you have to fold in two to eat. A definite must for any pizza lover!!!
Best pizza around if you are looking for a mom and pop NY style pizza! We always get “well done” for the perfect pie!
Having eaten at quite a few pizza shops in Queens I think I can say this is about the closest you’ll find to NY pizza in the Memphis area. Both in the building, service and pizza, sold by the slice and by the whole pie. A lot of take out went out the door during the time we were here. Both fountain drinks and bottles beverages. Lunch specials. I’ll be back.
Wow, really amazing pizza, you definitely need to try the cheese pizza “AMAZING” I’m definitely returning. The owner has been Making pizza’s for 28 years in New York so it’s definitely the real deal
Small pizza place in Collierville. We want to try something other than a chain pizza place and we decided to try this place based on the reviews. WOW! We were NOT disappointed. The extra wait to get the food was completely worth it. Our kids said it was the best food ever. We’d have to agree! We want to come back and try more speciality pizzas (adult friendly haha) and appetizers.
BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD IN MEMPHIS TN! This is New York Pizza in its truest form. I highly recommend stopping by and trying anything on the menu. You will be throughly impressed by New York Style Pizzeria’s refreshing authenticity!
Hands down the best pizza in or around Memphis. We have tried almost every pizza place and no other one even comes close. The place is clean, the staff is nice, and the Pizza is Awesome. It is the closest to NY style you will find. Our new favorite Mom and Pop pizza shop!
If you’re hungry for Pizza and want something quick to satisfy your appetite, this is the SPOT to go! The atmosphere is inviting, sit near the window and enjoy a slice or get a whole pie. They had lots of options. Friendly staff. The pizza was so good! Thin, crispy, and airy all the way through to the crust. Had a nice visit with my sister and enjoyed our Pizza slice and Convo
Location
-
1996 S Houston Levee Rd #103, Collierville, TN 38017, United States Hotline: +1 901-426-3219
Welcome to New York Style Pizzeria, the culinary gem nestled in the heart of Collierville, TN. Here, authenticity meets passion as the owner, with 28 years of pizza-making experience from the bustling streets of New York, brings the true taste of NY-style pizza to Tennessee.
As soon as you step into this cozy pizzeria located at 1996 S Houston Levee Rd #103, the aroma of freshly baked pizza envelops you, setting the stage for a delightful experience. The standout feature of New York Style Pizzeria is undoubtedly its chewy crust, which customers like Jason Alcock appreciate for its perfect texture. His sentiment, “Damn good pizza!” encapsulates the excitement many feel when faced with the oversized slices that New Yorkers are famous for—just the way pizza is meant to be enjoyed, folded in half to savor every bite.
It's no wonder customers like Ashley Rashid have proclaimed this pizzeria a local treasure. When she requests her pizza “well done,” it’s not just a tip—it's the secret to perfection here. Beyond the classic offerings, there’s a commitment to crafting a pizza experience that stands apart from the typical chain-store fare, making it a beloved choice among locals.
Another satisfied patron, John Kasper, praises it as “the closest you’ll find to NY pizza in the Memphis area.” With options to order by the slice or as a whole pie, the pizzeria effectively caters to both quick visits and larger gatherings. The lively atmosphere, enhanced by the steady flow of takeout orders, echoes the vibrant, bustling pizza shops of New York.
One of the highlights you’ll want to experience is the famous cheese pizza, as VALABASAS puts it—“AMAZING!” The simple yet rich flavors truly showcase the quality of ingredients. This makes every slice a joyful celebration of flavor. And for families looking for a meal that satisfies all ages, customer Caroline Balton agrees: even her kids declared it “the best food ever,” and it’s easy to understand why after just one taste.
So, if you are on the hunt for a memorable pizza experience that captures the essence of New York, make your way to New York Style Pizzeria. With an array of specialty pizzas and delectable appetizers waiting to be explored, you might just find yourself turning into a regular. Because here, it’s not just about the food. It’s about a slice of New York, right at your doorstep.
For orders or inquiries, feel free to reach out at +1 901-426-3219. Your next pizza night could be just a call away!